deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

Featured in Groups:

Details

June 14, 2012
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 5
Favourites: 0
Views: 1,636 (0 today)
[x]
Does anyone else find it disappointing when they're asked to do art that looks like another artist? Perhaps I bring this upon myself by not settling into one medium, one genre, and one style. I take a small amount of art jobs on the side and they vary greatly. The ones that are bothering me more and more are the ones that go something like "Wow, you are an amazing artist, you're prefect for this spot illustration I need. I think I would like the style to be more like Skottie Young." I should probably be flattered that his name was included in the same sentence as my art... but really it just feels backwards to me. If you want art that looks like Skottie's, then you go commission Skottie. I think the fun thing about art and illustration is to see the different styles and interpretations artists bring. I really don't care for art that looks recycled or formulaic. I love the unique filter every artist has and to see how they translate with art. I love the Arthur Rackhams version of Alice in Wonderland. I also like Bobby Chiu's concept art for Alice in Wonderland. The fun in following different artists is to see what the world looks like through their personal art filter. It's not as exciting to see them copy another artists filter. I know these rules don't apply when you're working for a studio film. However, if you're commissioned as an artist... shouldn't be odd to be asked to look like another artist? Anyone else struggle with this one?
Add a Comment:
 
:iconjunkomatic:
100% agree with you
Reply
:iconwheresmytea:
~wheresmytea Jun 14, 2012  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I totally agree with your 'liking to see the world through their art filter' approach to appreciating art. It's exactly why I follow artists with widely varying styles. :)

I have personally never run into this problem. The only illustration work that I've done is scientific. Exact detail and ease of understanding (largely based on composition and highlight vs shadow) are what my employers have looked for. I have had people take pause with the idea of working in markers, which is really my favourite medium right now. :/
Reply
:iconwhiteflyinglizard:
Thank you! I'm glad to hear I'm not the only one who loves following a myriad of different styles and genres of art.
To be honest, this problem of styles hasn't happened to me very often. This last time I sat down with a client (who was interviewing different artists for a project) I got the line "you're really good. I just want you to make you art look like this last artist I talked to". Luckily I think she did end up hiring that artist in the end.
... and I'm with you on the markers. I'm not great with them, but I love them and the look you can get with them. Thanks for sharing.
Reply
:iconoddstuffs:
*Oddstuffs Jun 14, 2012  Professional General Artist
It happens a lot. People can't afford the artists they want or the ones they want aren't available to commission, so they turn to others to do it for them. I agree with you, it's kinda insulting. It could be taken as a compliment that they think you're flexible enough to do anything, but it's also frustrating that they don't want work that's strictly you.
Reply
:iconwhiteflyinglizard:
Yeah, I guess it's the "they don't want work that's strictly you" that is odd. I understand an art director describing a project this way. I understand studios making artists conform to a style. I don't understand personal commissions from fans that would want anything but that artist’s version. If I ask Peter De Seve for a sketch of peter pan it's because I want to see what peter pan looks like to him. Even if I ask an artist who's not very accomplished, I still want to see their personal version. I would never be bummed that my sketch from De Seve doesn't look enough like NC Wyeth. Thanks for your thoughts on this. I'm happy to hear others see this same thing.
Reply
Add a Comment: